Animal-based vs. Carnivore. A friendly debate with Anthony Chaffee, MD

PS

Paul Saladino1h 23m · 2023-09-12

Claims Made

145

Claims Supported

91

Support Rate

63%

Support rate

91 of 145 claims supported

91 supported54 partial / not

Claims from this content

115

Well SupportedInsulin resistance makes LDL 'stickier,' increasing cardiac risk, while individuals who are insulin sensitive show no increase in cardiac risk with higher LDL levels.Well SupportedA recommended intake for organ meats is a few ounces per week, such as half an ounce to a few ounces of liver and a few ounces of heart per week.Well SupportedIndividuals with high caffeine sensitivity should avoid caffeine for 14-15 hours before sleep, while less sensitive individuals need 8-10 hours.Not SupportedLong-term ketosis can lead to significant electrolyte insufficiency, impaired thyroid function, and lower body temperatures.Well Supported

Discussion

Native comments, Twitter mentions, and Reddit threads about this content — surfaced together so the conversation isn't fragmented across platforms.

M

Share your read of this content…

Posting publicly as you · linked to your social profiles

Sort by:

AV

A. Volkovreader

4h

Bookmarking — the dossier-vs-overview split is the right call. Most of the time I want overview; sometimes I want receipts.

NP

N. Park

2d

Would love a "what would change this verdict" RSS feed. Sign me up if it exists.

Consuming plants without considering their chemical defenses can pose a significant health risk.

Well SupportedFruit juices can improve endothelial function, decrease lipid peroxidation, and decrease DNA damage.

Well SupportedAdopting a carnivore diet followed by an animal-based diet for four years resolved the speaker's eczema and asthma.

Well SupportedFreshly squeezed red orange juice can be beneficial for the endothelium when consumed in moderation.

Well SupportedFruit and even fruit juice are unequivocally beneficial for human health, potentially due to fiber content mitigating fructose absorption.

Partially SupportedThe Hard Soil 'Whole Package' supplement is not Informed Sports certified because it contains naturally occurring testosterone and other androgens.

Well SupportedLiver and egg yolks are excellent sources of vitamin A for carnivore diets.

Well SupportedConsuming carbohydrates from tolerated sources like fruit, honey, or tubers can positively impact thyroid and sex hormones.

Well SupportedFruits contain vitamin C and other vitamins and minerals that mitigate the effects of fructose in the body.

Not SupportedPaul Saladino believes coffee polyphenols are not beneficial and suggests coffee may contain mold toxins, acrylamide, and pesticides.

Well SupportedOrgan meats like liver and kidney are necessary for obtaining adequate riboflavin, especially for those with MTHFR polymorphisms.

Well SupportedIndividuals who switched from plant-based diets to higher-fat, higher-meat diets reported resolution of health issues and improved well-being.

Well SupportedIndividuals should experiment with their diet by cutting out and reintroducing foods to observe how they feel.

Well SupportedCoffee contains defense chemicals and plant compounds that can cause inflammation, leading to increased muscle soreness and joint pain after exercise.

Well SupportedWatermelon juice consumed with an oral glucose tolerance test attenuates negative endothelial effects.

Partially SupportedA small fraction of animals are poisonous, while the majority of animals and their parts are edible and not toxic.

Well SupportedHeart & Soil's 'Whole Package' supplement contains testicle and liver and is intended to support testosterone levels.

Not SupportedLong-term ketosis can negatively affect cortisol metabolism, thyroid hormones, and other physiological functions in some individuals.

Partially SupportedRaw meat and raw liver contain significant amounts of glycogen, which is consumed by the Inuit.

Partially SupportedHigher saturated fat consumption is associated with protection against stroke, while lower consumption increases stroke risk.

Partially SupportedSome vegetables are not beneficial for human health.

Partially SupportedInuit and Hadza cultures consume organs from the animals they eat, suggesting organs are evolutionarily consistent and critical for human diets.

Partially SupportedVitamin A toxicity is often associated with vitamin A palmitate supplements rather than consumption of cow's liver.

Not SupportedReintroducing fruits and vegetables, or specifically fruit and honey, can lead to relapse for individuals with a history of serious carb addiction or weight issues.

Well SupportedProcessed sugars, particularly from sugar-sweetened beverages, are detrimental to human health.

Not SupportedThe idea that LDL cholesterol is harmful is difficult to accept given its essential biological functions and potentially fraudulent historical studies.

Partially SupportedMany people are leaving the plant-based movement, and returning to eating meat leads to significant health improvements.

Partially SupportedCaffeic acid and chlorogenic acid in coffee can cause harm in certain body parts for some individuals.

Not SupportedSugar companies manipulated studies and data to falsely implicate cholesterol in heart disease and promote sugar consumption.

Not SupportedPolar bear liver consumption may be problematic due to high vitamin A and cadmium contamination.

Partially SupportedIn studies of patients having heart attacks, approximately 50% had high LDL cholesterol and 50% had low normal LDL cholesterol.

Partially SupportedSwitching to an all-meat diet resulted in a 23-pound weight loss and significant muscle gain in 10 days.

Partially SupportedNutrients like taurine and CoQ10, which play a role in heart health, are highly concentrated in the heart organ meat.

Partially SupportedA majority of people who eliminate animal foods from their diet develop health issues requiring them to reintroduce animal foods.

Partially SupportedBlocking 30% of sugar absorption with fiber can help stabilize blood sugar.

Partially SupportedThe carnivore diet can lead to rapid body composition changes and improved strength, even in individuals over 50.

Partially SupportedA vegan diet is better than a processed food diet, but processed foods are often plant-based.

Partially SupportedAn orthopedic surgeon experienced no soreness after a hard workout on a carnivore diet, but became sore after drinking coffee.

Partially SupportedOne ounce of polar bear liver contains the vitamin A equivalent of approximately seven pounds of cow's liver.

Not SupportedConsuming very large amounts of liver (e.g., 6-10 ounces daily) long-term is not considered beneficial or evolutionarily consistent for humans.

Not SupportedConsuming one cup of black coffee caused muscle stiffness and soreness for two days.

Partially SupportedEvolutionarily consistent amounts of liver are healthful for humans, especially during pregnancy.

Partially SupportedExcessive consumption of organ meats can lead to detrimental buildup of vitamin A, copper, or other substances.

Partially SupportedTesticles consumed as animal food appear more bioavailable and effective than other testosterone boosters.

Partially SupportedHigher LDL cholesterol levels are associated with slightly improved mortality, and lower LDL levels are associated with the highest mortality rates.

Partially SupportedHigh LDL cholesterol, with high HDL and low triglycerides, is associated with a 1% per year reduction in all-cause mortality.

Limited ResearchStudies on fruit juice benefits may be confounded if conducted within the context of a generally poor diet, and the observed benefits might not translate to individuals with a healthy diet.

Partially SupportedIndividuals should adopt dietary approaches that they find beneficial and that improve their well-being.

Partially SupportedEating only meat and eggs for five years in his early twenties made Anthony Chaffee feel better than ever.

Partially SupportedCutting out vegetables contradicts common health advice and surprises many people.

Partially SupportedDefense chemicals in vegetables, such as oxalates, may accumulate in joints and contribute to joint pain.

Partially SupportedResearch on processed sugars and high-fructose corn syrup may be conflated with research on fruit, leading to the incorrect conclusion that fruit is bad for humans.

Partially SupportedAthletes on higher carbohydrate diets have improved free testosterone to cortisol ratios and better immune function after intense exercise compared to those on low-carbohydrate diets.

Partially SupportedIndividuals can empower themselves to be their own physicians by understanding available tools like dietary and lifestyle adjustments.

Partially SupportedPeople can likely consume as much heart meat as they desire.

Partially SupportedThe speaker eats one large meal per day and feels best doing so.

Partially SupportedEliminating coffee from the diet for 30 days can lead to feeling better for most people.

Partially SupportedCardiovascular death rates are increasing globally.

Partially SupportedThe incidence and prevalence of first-time heart attacks are increasing, despite improvements in medical interventions.

Partially SupportedExcessive vitamin A intake from organs can cause hypervitaminosis A and suppress TSH.

Partially SupportedCholesterol is essential for human physiology, forming cell membranes, hormones, bile, and myelin sheaths.

Partially SupportedProcessed foods, seed oils, high fructose corn syrup, and processed sugar are considered bigger health problems than vegetables for most people.

Not SupportedAncel Keys and others misrepresented data to promote sugar and vilify cholesterol.

Partially SupportedFiber can block approximately 30% of intestinal absorption.

Partially SupportedThe traditional Inuit diet derives approximately 50% of calories from fat, 30-35% from protein, and 15-20% from carbohydrates.

Partially SupportedThe speaker relies on first principles and how he feels to gauge ketosis rather than regularly checking ketone levels.

Partially SupportedConsuming a large bolus of protein can transiently raise insulin levels and potentially kick one out of ketosis.

Partially SupportedFor individuals recovering from psychological food addiction, abstaining from carbohydrates may be necessary, but for others, reincorporating carbohydrates like fruit juice, fruit, and honey is acceptable and evolutionarily consistent.

Partially SupportedIndividuals who transition to a vegan diet and report feeling better may have made numerous other lifestyle changes simultaneously.

Partially SupportedEating large quantities of vegetables like kale, spinach, and broccoli in smoothies tasted wretched and bitter.

Partially SupportedThe speaker predominantly ate whole foods, including chicken and beef, with a focus on meat and vegetables, and limited carbohydrates like bread and pasta.

Partially SupportedFructose consumption can be problematic, with potential for negative outcomes depending on study design and who is conducting it.

Partially SupportedLong-term carnivores suggest salt may be addictive and contribute to overeating.

Partially SupportedA whole food plant-based diet may not be optimal for health.

Not SupportedChronically affecting sleep architecture is detrimental to human health and will likely lead to accelerated aging and early cognitive decline.

Partially SupportedIndividuals improving on a vegan diet may do so by eliminating processed foods, alcohol, and cigarettes, not necessarily by excluding meat.

Partially SupportedA diet can be vegan and still include unhealthy items like Oreos and drugs.

Partially SupportedA vegan diet can cause severe fatigue.

Partially SupportedThe vitamin A content in the liver of carnivore animals is likely to be quite high.

Partially SupportedJoint pain almost invariably improves when people cut out vegetables.

Partially Supported60-80% of individuals who cut out vegetables experience significant improvements in their health.

Partially SupportedA 2020 review found no correlation between saturated fat consumption and heart disease, and no upper limit for intake.

Partially SupportedCaffeine pills provide energy and focus without the negative side effects experienced with coffee.

Not SupportedThe incidence rate of first-time heart attacks has increased despite a decrease in cholesterol-lowering interventions.

Partially SupportedThe speaker has historically eaten whole foods, with meals primarily consisting of meat and vegetables, and has not typically consumed processed foods.

Partially SupportedThere is no mirrored statistic for people who cut out all plants or vegetables showing a significant percentage returning to eating them due to health issues.

Partially SupportedNeurosurgical patients with radiculopathy or pinched nerves often benefit from dietary changes, showing symptom and pain improvement.

Partially SupportedAn all-meat diet eliminated brain fog and significantly improved eye redness.

Not SupportedThe Framingham study's conclusion that cholesterol causes heart disease was a misrepresentation of the data.

Partially SupportedImprovements attributed to adopting a vegan diet may be due to broader lifestyle changes such as cooking at home, reducing alcohol and smoking, and avoiding restaurants and processed sugars.

Not SupportedLDL cholesterol was falsely accused as a cause of heart disease, serving as a scapegoat for the sugar industry.

Partially SupportedAdjusting diet and lifestyle, particularly through specific dietary tweaks, can be a powerful lever for health.

Partially SupportedPolar bear liver contains over 100 times more vitamin A than ruminant liver, making it potentially toxic in small amounts.

Partially SupportedIndividuals may experience joint pain and could consider cutting out spinach, broccoli, or kale, or eating fewer salads.

Partially SupportedPlant defense chemicals can exacerbate pain and soreness after exercise.

Partially SupportedAn evolved diet consisting solely of meat is biologically optimal for humans.

Not SupportedCoffee consumption can exacerbate allergies and negatively impact well-being due to potential dust and mold content.

Not SupportedCoffee contains defense chemicals that can cause inflammatory reactions.

Partially SupportedKetosis can significantly alter cortisol metabolism in obese men, increasing 11 beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase type one.

Partially SupportedSome individuals experience worsening health on a whole-foods, plant-based diet and improve upon reintroducing meat.

Partially SupportedReducing vegetables and increasing meat intake can lead to significant weight loss and improved energy.

Partially SupportedDr. Tony Hampton concluded that meat is necessary and some plants are harmful after eight years of being vegan/vegetarian.

Partially SupportedThe correlation between LDL cholesterol and cardiovascular disease may be linked to environmental toxins, smoking, or heavy metals damaging the endothelium, rather than LDL itself.

Partially SupportedEating a natural human diet can lead to health and well-being.

Partially SupportedMany commonly consumed vegetables contain identified human carcinogens.

Partially SupportedFollowing a meat-only diet for 5-6 weeks improved the speaker's athleticism and energy levels, as indicated by their performance in a modified bleep test.

Partially SupportedA vegan diet is a good first step towards an intentional dietary choice.

Partially SupportedCutting out a food or substance for 30 days and observing the effects is a good test for dietary sensitivities.

Partially SupportedStudies examining individuals in ketosis for 24 months show stable cortisol and thyroid function, with other markers improving or remaining the same.

Not SupportedFollowing the 1977 USDA declaration, Americans reduced red meat and saturated fat intake, while increasing consumption of carbohydrates, sugar, and seed oils, leading to a tripling of heart disease rates.

Not SupportedA Harvard professor involved in falsifying cholesterol data authored the 1977 USDA declaration recommending reduced cholesterol and saturated fat.