today the mechanism by which metformin works is debated hotly but what I think is not debated is the immediate thing that metformin does which is it inhibits complex one of the mitochondria
The evidence is convergent. Multiple independent sources reach the same conclusion, the underlying mechanism is well-characterized, and even the field's most cautious voices treat it as worth doing.
today the mechanism by which metformin works is debated hotly but what I think is not debated is the immediate thing that metformin does which is it inhibits complex one of the mitochondria
Every Sunday: the week’s new conflicts and verdict changes — and nothing else.
Native comments, Twitter mentions, and Reddit threads about this claim — surfaced together so the conversation isn't fragmented across platforms.
Bookmarking — the dossier-vs-overview split is the right call. Most of the time I want overview; sometimes I want receipts.
Would love a "what would change this verdict" RSS feed. Sign me up if it exists.
so the mitochondria as everybody thinks of those as the cellular engine for making ATP so the most efficient way that we make ATP is through oxidative phosphorylation where we take either fatty acid pieces or a breakdown product of glucose once it's partially metabolized to pyruvate we put that into an electron transport chain and we basically trade chemical energy for electrons that can then be used to make phosphates onto ADP
so so you know something like cyanide that is a very potent inhibitor of this electron transport chain will kill you instantly people understand that of course a drop of Cyanide and you would you would be dead literally instantaneously yeah so metformin works at the first of those complexes I believe there are four if my memory serves correctly four electron transport chain complexes and um but of course it's not a complete inhibition of it it's just kind of a weak Blocker of that
metformin is a partial complex one inhibitor if complex one is shut down you cannot move nadh through the electron transport chain which means that you are completely dependent on fatty acid oxidation you can't move nadh you can't use glycolysis to use to generate the reducing equivalents that are going to move through complex one you can't do glycolysis
it's a known inhibitor of complex one of the electro transport chain and as perhaps the one complex that is with complex four probably close second the one complex that is known to be inhibited in every type of cancer
metformin inhibits complex one so Matt Forman lowers the ratio of nad to NADH does it has that been shown so you're saying it should lower it it should lower it
so what metformin and doesn't allow is it starts to weakly inhibit complex once so your NADH to nad he is going to be slowed down
we think metformin is a weak mitochondrial complex one inhibitor yes another which is part of the respiratory chain
we could show clearly these shut it down yeah yeah with metformin you could decrease it when the yeast complex you can recover that ratio the nad to NADH ratio
so it gets to the mitochondria and in the mitochondria it basically changes ATP ATP ratio and that's a lot of it is important in the liver but not only to the extent that there is an activation of a MP kinase and near is there a demonstrable reduction in nad to NADH in that cell when complex one is inhibited yes yeah absolutely those studies have been have been done
of course metformin hits complex one I think that's undeniable
Would that make metformin a bad idea from this standpoint? Because metformin inhibits complex one. So metformin lowers the ratio of NAD to NADH. Does it? Has that been shown? No. So you're saying it should lower it? It should lower it.
metformin of course is a super interesting medication and probably works you know mainly by slowing the conversion of nadh backed nad by impairing the complex one of the electron transport chain the one that does this initial electron offloading from nadh to make nad
metformin works at the first of those complexes I believe there are four if my memory serves correctly four electron transport chain complexes and um but of course it's not a complete inhibition of it it's just kind of a weak Blocker of that
the conventional thinking on Metformin is it's inhibiting complex one of the mitochondria correct yeah and if you inhibit complex one you're God you're activating am kinas that should reduce hepatic glucose output correct
So they're looking at it from that perspective.