in both of these graphs the downward trending line from the controls so again non-diabetic not taking metformin is above the line corresponding to the diabetics who are taking metformin um put crudely um the people who are taking metformin that have diabetes are dying at a faster rate for every single year exam and the two lines do not overlap except at the beginning when everyone's alive it's like a foot race where basically the people with metformin and diabetes are falling behind and dying as they fall