Red meat is a health food, with Stephan Van Vliet

PS

Paul Saladino1h 48m · 2021-09-07

Claims Made

181

Claims Supported

110

Support Rate

61%

Support rate

110 of 181 claims supported

110 supported71 partial / not

Claims from this content

145

Well SupportedThe Hadza people feed their children meat and fruit and generally do not eat vegetables, leaves, stems, or seeds unless necessary.Well SupportedPure fructose or processed sugars like high-fructose corn syrup should not be conflated with whole-food carbohydrate sources such as fruit or honey.Well SupportedLinoleic acid in seed oils increases anandamide and 2-AG in the brain, which binds to CB1 receptors and induces hunger.Well SupportedProcessed foods contribute to overeating and weight gain by negatively affecting metabolism and hormones, increasing hunger and reducing satiety.Well Supported

Discussion

Native comments, Twitter mentions, and Reddit threads about this content — surfaced together so the conversation isn't fragmented across platforms.

M

Share your read of this content…

Posting publicly as you · linked to your social profiles

Sort by:

AV

A. Volkovreader

4h

Bookmarking — the dossier-vs-overview split is the right call. Most of the time I want overview; sometimes I want receipts.

NP

N. Park

2d

Would love a "what would change this verdict" RSS feed. Sign me up if it exists.

The Heart & Soil histamine and immune supplement may improve allergies.

Partially SupportedA diet with greater than five portions of fruit and vegetables per day for 12 weeks showed no changes in any biomarkers compared to less than two portions.

Well SupportedPaul Saladino advocates for an animal-based diet as the most optimal for humans, citing it as the least toxic and most nutrient-rich and bioavailable.

Well SupportedHeart and Soil supplements 'Whole Package' contain testicle and 'Memory and Brain' contain brain, which may be beneficial for libido and cognition.

Well SupportedRed meat and organs are considered incredibly health-promoting for humans when consumed within the context of a healthy diet.

Well SupportedHumans historically prioritized animal foods over plant-based foods when available.

Well SupportedEating organs provides nutrients not found in vegetables and enhances overall health.

Well SupportedConsuming a significant amount of animal source foods, including meat and organs like liver, is needed to truly thrive.

Well SupportedOverall diet quality, rather than specific food components, appears to be the primary factor influencing cancer incidence.

Well SupportedVegetarians have reduced carnitine levels and transport, which is problematic as carnitine is essential for human functioning.

Well SupportedThe perceived health benefits of vegetarianism may be due to 'healthy user bias'.

Well SupportedIncreasing lean red meat intake by replacing carbohydrates does not elevate markers of oxidative stress and inflammation.

Well SupportedOrgan meats concentrate polyphenols to a higher degree than muscle meat.

Well SupportedThe nutritional quality of meat is influenced by what the cow eats, suggesting that grass-fed, grass-finished, regeneratively raised cows provide superior nutrition.

Well SupportedHigh heat processing of unstable fats in seed oils makes them worse than refining stable fats like beef tallow.

Well SupportedPhytic acid is not completely reduced by processing, and lectins are difficult to remove from foods like beans without pressure cooking.

Well SupportedMeat from animals raised on biodiverse pastures is richer in phytochemicals than meat from animals grazing monoculture pastures or finished in feedlots on grain.

Well SupportedHealth-promoting phytonutrients are found in higher concentrations in grass-fed meat and milk compared to factory-farmed animals.

Well SupportedEating animal foods, particularly organs, is central to human health and was sought after by ancestors and currently living hunter-gatherers.

Not SupportedVegan and vegetarian diets are not considered viable or evolutionarily consistent for humans.

Partially SupportedKangaroo meat consumption resulted in a slightly lower inflammatory response compared to wagyu beef.

Not SupportedPlants contain compounds that are not beneficial long-term.

Not SupportedResearch on pure fructose, processed sugars, and high-fructose corn syrup should not be conflated with studies on whole food carbohydrate sources like fruit or honey.

Partially SupportedReductionist thinking in nutritional medicine is detrimental; focus on studies using real foods and do not fear carbohydrates like fructose and glucose found in honey or fruit, as they are accompanied by micronutrients that support optimal function and nitric oxide synthesis.

Partially SupportedPaul Saladino avoids vegetables due to their oxalate content.

Partially SupportedVegetarians and non-vegetarians with healthy behaviors had similar low mortality rates in the UK Shopper study.

Partially SupportedModerate meat consumption is associated with benefits in Asian prospective cohort studies.

Partially SupportedPhytochemicals are 5 to 20 times lower in animal source foods than in plant sources, with unknown bioavailability.

Partially SupportedHistorical detoxification of plant foods suggests their lower relative value in diets.

Partially SupportedMeat contains antioxidant compounds like carnosine, carnitine, and taurine that may offer neurocognitive benefits.

Well SupportedPeople tend to overeat approximately 500 calories on ultra-processed foods.

Well SupportedWhole foods require more energy to digest and have more volume than ultra-processed foods, aiding in short-term food intake regulation.

Partially SupportedEating liver is recommended for health benefits.

Partially SupportedNutrients like taurine and CoQ10, which play a role in heart health, are highly concentrated in the heart organ meat.

Partially SupportedCompounds like anserine, taurine, and carnosine, found in meat, can play potential antioxidant roles.

Not SupportedThe advice to 'eat more plants' is not optimal for everyone.

Partially SupportedSome individuals may not respond well to high fat intake and ketosis, and there is a spectrum of response.

Partially SupportedThe bioavailability of some compounds from animal source foods may not differ from plant foods due to the absence of inhibitory compounds.

Partially SupportedFructose is not a concern when consumed in whole food forms like meat, bananas, or honey.

Partially SupportedStudies on red meat consumption often focus on individuals consuming standard American diets, which are largely composed of ultra-processed foods.

Well SupportedThe association between red meat consumption and negative health outcomes is not as strong or compelling as often portrayed.

Partially SupportedHigh-fat ground beef consumption improved flow-mediated dilation and lowered systolic and diastolic blood pressure.

Partially SupportedA significant majority of former vegans and vegetarians abandoned these diets within 12 months.

Partially SupportedHuman dietary needs may be flexible and vary across cultures and environments.

Partially SupportedFeeding animals a biodiverse forage diet can increase antioxidant compounds in their meat, potentially decreasing lipid oxidation.

Partially SupportedMarinades, herbs, spices, or citrus can reduce the formation of heterocyclic amines when meat is heated.

Partially SupportedThere are intra-individual differences in how nutrients are metabolized, contributing to varying responses to certain diets.

Partially SupportedWhole foods, like fruits, apples, and honey, contain information beyond single nutrients that affects metabolism.

Partially SupportedTraditional cultures employed detoxification methods for plant foods, and failure to process foods like corn led to issues such as pellagra.

Partially SupportedCo-consuming meat with fruits and vegetables provides bioavailable nutrients and may offset negative effects through the combined food matrix.

Partially SupportedPecorino cheese from sheep raised on biodiverse mountain pastures in Sardinia is associated with a lower chronic systemic inflammatory response.

Partially SupportedCompounds like catechin, found in green tea, are present in similar amounts in high-end grass-fed milk as in some green teas.

Partially SupportedTraditional diets like pemmican combined foods to preserve nutrients and mitigate potential harm.

Partially SupportedVegetables may require more processing, such as sprouting or fermenting, to become safe and digestible compared to fruits.

Partially SupportedA healthy diet is evolutionarily consistent, free from processed foods, and predominantly composed of whole foods.

Partially SupportedPhytochemicals from fruits and vegetables may have anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects that can offset potential oxidation from red meat.

Partially SupportedGrass-fed beef contains potentially beneficial compounds such as creatine and carnosine, which may have antioxidant and neurocognitive effects.

Partially SupportedNutrients that play a role in specific human organs are often most recently expressed in the same organ of the animal, suggesting a potential overlap that warrants further study.

Partially SupportedIt is difficult to fully separate the health benefits of a whole foods diet from its caloric intake, as people may struggle to consume the same number of calories on a whole foods diet compared to an ultra-processed diet.

Partially SupportedPaul Saladino is establishing a non-profit to fund research comparing diets with and without vegetables.

Partially SupportedAdding herbs, spices, and marinades can mitigate potential carcinogens formed when red meat is consumed with ultra-processed foods.

Partially SupportedPeptides, sequences of less than 50 amino acids, may have unique signaling roles and could be found in specific organs, potentially impacting human health.

Partially SupportedUnderstanding whether meat's health effects are due to absence of ultra-processed foods or presence of other foods is needed for dietary choices.

Partially SupportedCholesterol changes may take longer than four weeks to manifest in dietary studies.

Partially SupportedA study will examine inflammatory profiles, including interleukin-6 and C-reactive protein, and utilize metabolomics to analyze blood metabolites.

Partially SupportedPlant-based meat alternatives and grass-fed beef are not nutritionally interchangeable due to significantly different metabolites.

Partially SupportedN-nitroso compounds formed during meat cooking differ from those that induce tumorigenesis via DNA adducts.

Partially SupportedOrgan meats like liver, heart, and kidney have a distinct food matrix compared to muscle meat.

Partially SupportedIndividual sensitivity to vegetables like broccoli varies, with some experiencing adverse reactions and others not.

Partially SupportedHuman nutritional biochemistry is largely similar across individuals, suggesting a common optimal dietary construction.

Partially SupportedA traditional American diet rich in whole grains and potatoes did not significantly change fasting insulin levels in participants at weight maintenance.

Partially SupportedThe theory that lipids in meat oxidize during cooking and herbs ameliorate this is not proven beyond reasonable doubt.

Partially SupportedThe Standard American Diet is likely higher in linoleic acid due to processed foods cooked in vegetable oil.

Partially SupportedWhole foods diets may be more satiating due to nutrient richness, but the satiating effect from fiber is less convincing.

Partially SupportedPaul Saladino now distinguishes between plant defense chemicals and other plant compounds.

Partially SupportedIndividual responses to foods and diets vary significantly, with studies on 20 humans yielding approximately 20 different responses.

Partially SupportedObservational studies have a role in nutrition science but are not definitive for precise health impact estimations.

Partially SupportedPlant-based meat alternatives contain isoflavones and other phenolic antioxidants, such as genistein and daidzein.

Partially SupportedStephan Van Vliet found long-term ketosis difficult and felt better with some carbohydrates for electrolyte balance on a carnivore diet.

Partially SupportedFructose from sugar-sweetened beverages has different metabolic effects than fructose consumed from whole foods.

Not SupportedThe speaker no longer believes fructose is inherently bad for humans.

Partially SupportedA Mediterranean diet pattern is generally characterized by higher levels of alpha-linolenic acid and lower levels of linoleic acid.

Partially SupportedHigh-profile vegans may not be as healthy as they present and could potentially be healthier with the addition of meat.

Partially SupportedIndividuals with chronic kidney disease generally do not tolerate high protein intake well and may not do well on a heavily meat-based diet.

Partially SupportedAnserine and taurine are found in sources other than meat, including fish, and creatine is also found in fish.

Not SupportedBe cautious about extrapolating findings from specific dietary groups to entire populations.

Partially SupportedPhytochemicals may be beneficial when obtained from animals that have processed them, such as herbivores eating biodiverse diets.

Partially SupportedMost nutrition studies are conducted on populations consuming standard American diets, which are largely composed of ultra-processed foods.

Partially SupportedIndividuals should avoid foods like broccoli if they consistently cause gut issues, as nutrients can be obtained from alternative sources.

Partially SupportedOrgan meats have a higher total antioxidant capacity than other foods.

Partially SupportedDietary diversity, including a wider variety of phytochemicals from various plant sources, is associated with better health outcomes.

Partially SupportedA specific diet improved triglycerides significantly within four weeks in a randomized controlled trial.

Partially SupportedUltra-processed foods are typically lower in secondary compounds and phytochemicals compared to whole foods.

Partially SupportedConsuming meat as part of a healthier diet may mitigate potential problems associated with meat consumption.

Partially SupportedObservations from the Hadza and Ikong people are consistent with a hierarchy of foods prioritized by humans.

Partially SupportedPaul Saladino no longer fears fructose, acknowledging he was previously misled.

Partially SupportedThe overall diet has a more dramatic effect on health and disease association than individual foods.

Partially SupportedCompounds like oxalates in green leafy vegetables are better digested after cooking.

Partially SupportedConsuming a more diverse diet can increase the presence of phytochemicals found in meat.

Partially SupportedThe health associations of foods like eggs and red meat are significantly modified by the overall dietary background.

Partially SupportedA Mediterranean-style diet can improve multiple cardiometabolic risk factors in overweight or obese adults.

Partially SupportedIn the general Westernized population, individuals who eat red meat often consume it as part of a meal with processed foods rather than as a standalone healthy food.

Partially SupportedA study finding a 20% increase in disease with red meat consumption showed no increased risk of metabolic disease in individuals with a low BMI and a healthy lifestyle, once BMI was accounted for.

Partially SupportedStudies examining red meat consumption within a high-quality omnivorous diet context have not found the same negative health results as studies on standard American diets.

Partially SupportedConsuming red meat as part of a healthy omnivorous diet rich in fruits and vegetables does not increase plasma oxidation products.

Partially SupportedRemoving ultra-processed foods from the diet is significant, and moderate amounts of red meat may be beneficial in their absence.

Partially SupportedFew people appear to do poorly on paleo, autoimmune paleo, or animal-based diets.

Partially SupportedMeat consumption itself was not associated with mortality in the Meat Consumption and Diet Quality and Mortality study.

Partially SupportedAnimals can incorporate unique phytochemicals like plant beta-pinene and terpenes into the human diet through animal source foods.

Partially SupportedIncluding beef as part of a DASH or Mediterranean diet does not appear to negatively impact health biomarkers.

Partially SupportedHomo sapiens are not evolutionarily adapted to a plant-based diet.

Partially SupportedPhytochemicals in meat and milk may have anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects, protecting against lipid peroxidation.

Partially SupportedAn animal-based diet of meat, organs, and fruit, without vegetables, needs to be studied for its effects on people.

Partially SupportedMetabolomic analysis revealed a 90% difference in metabolite abundance between grass-fed beef and a soy-based plant-based meat alternative.

Partially SupportedStudies found that when red meat is consumed as part of a healthy diet, associations with increased risk of metabolic disease may disappear.

Limited ResearchPhytochemicals may play a more significant protective role than the absence or presence of certain oils.

Limited ResearchThere are concerns about linoleic acid's role in health and its interaction with other dietary components.

Not SupportedVegan diets, which exclude dairy and eggs, may lead to hormonal collapse and severe nutritional deficiencies in individuals after 4-5 years.

Not SupportedNutrition science should avoid a one-size-fits-all approach and allow for personal freedom and cultural traditions.

Not SupportedHeme iron studies are often conducted in calcium-deficient rat models and many studies lack a meat matrix, which are methodological flaws.

Not SupportedA CNN report stating one hot dog shortens life by 30-36 minutes is an oversimplification.

Not SupportedThe hypothesis that meat consumption is harmful and requires protection from fruits and vegetables is not convincing.

Not SupportedLectins in foods like beans are a significant concern.

Not SupportedThe speaker has concerns about linoleic acid.

Not SupportedEstimating precise lifespan changes from individual foods is not feasible due to inherent uncertainties in nutrition science.

Partially SupportedIn a trial, the non-reduced red meat group consumed 350 grams of red meat per week, while the reduced group consumed 200 grams per week.

Partially SupportedThe food matrix of unprocessed meat, containing compounds like anserine and creatine, may offer neurocognitive and antioxidant benefits.

Partially SupportedStudies investigate whether daily high consumption of red meat modulates cardiometabolic risk factors.

Partially SupportedA DASH-like diet containing lean beef showed no significant effects on diastolic blood pressure or endothelial function.

Partially SupportedConsuming grass-fed, grass-finished, regeneratively raised beef may offer health benefits.

Partially SupportedThe digestion and absorption kinetics of ultra-processed foods are altered, leading to quicker nutrient circulation and disrupted satiety responses.

Partially SupportedN-nitroso compounds formed from cooking meat differ from N-nitroso species that induce tumorigenesis via DNA adducts, suggesting a distinction in their carcinogenic potential.

Partially SupportedIn animal models, calorie-rich but nutrient-poor diets lead to overeating as animals attempt to obtain necessary nutrients.

Partially SupportedFibers primarily function to expand the stomach volume, similar to how army rangers in indoctrination school would eat toilet paper and drink water to feel full.

Partially SupportedMost people tend to fall on a spectrum of omnivory, incorporating various amounts of plants and animal products.

Partially SupportedConsuming sugar from sources like sweet potatoes or apples does not inherently make these foods unhealthy.

Partially SupportedThe background diet significantly impacts whether individual foods are associated with health or disease.

Partially SupportedPhytochemicals from forage are transferred into the meat and milk of grazing animals.

Partially SupportedCooking lipids in any food, including meat, can potentially lead to oxidation.

Partially SupportedThe matrix in which nutrients are consumed influences how the body metabolizes them.

Partially SupportedA moderate protein DASH-like diet including lean beef decreased systolic blood pressure in normal individuals.